THE ROLE OF THE SCOTTISH BUDGET IN STIMULATING INVESTMENT
By Paul Brewer, Senior Partner, PricewaterhouseCoopers LLP
‘A Budget for Recovery’
The Scottish economy continues to struggle its way out of the recession, which was shallower here than in the rest of the UK but slower to recover too. According to Scottish Government figures the Scottish economy grew by just 1.1% last year compared to 1.5% for the UK as a whole. The latest data from the Office for National Statistics estimates the current unemployment rate in Scotland at 8.6% with youth unemployment, those aged 16-24, reaching 102,000. In such conditions private sector businesses are wary and uncertain of their ability to generate timely and attractive returns on their investments.
Meanwhile the UK government’s policy of fiscal austerity remains firmly in place. The financial crisis exposed underlying fragility in the public finances and added to them with the bail out of key financial institutions. The constrained room for fiscal manoeuvre at a UK level was recently re-confirmed by Moody’s placing of a negative outlook on the UK’s cherished AAA credit rating, any future downgrade would serve to push up the UK’s borrowing costs. In spite of growing calls for fiscal stimulus in the face of flagging growth the UK government insists that balancing the books must remain the priority and Scotland must take its share of the pain.
The constrained room for fiscal manoeuvre at a UK level was recently re-confirmed by Moody's placing of a negative outlook on the UK's cherished AAA credit rating, any future downgrade would serve to push up the UK's borrowing costs.
Maintaining Investment in National Infrastructure
Looking at the first point Scotland is facing a headline 32% reduction in its devolved capital budget over the next 4 years. That the figure sounds so high is a result of the areas hardest hit at UK level in capital terms also carrying a heavy weighting in the Barnet formula which determines Scotland’s budget settlement. However the Scottish Government took an early decision to offset some of this and prioritise capital investment by diverting resources totalling £750m by 2014/15 from the revenue budgets, covering day-to-day spending and relatively less constrained with around a 9% reduction, towards capital investment. In total the core capital budget will be around £2.5bn in 2012/13 but this compares to a peak closer to £4bn in 2009/10.
In total the core capital budget will be around £2.5bn in 2012/13 but this compares to a peak closer to £4bn in 2009/10
The Scottish Government is also keen to avoid past situations from which we are still recovering where short term cuts and capital underinvestment has stored up a much costlier long term problem. Compared to the scale of investment required in the public sector estate – the Scottish Government's recent State of the Estate report identified a £1bn maintenance backlog in the NHS estate in Scotland for example - the capital budget announced will still need aggressive prioritisation, with many perceived needs not met.
The publication last December of the Scottish Government’s updated infrastructure investment plan gives an idea of these priorities. By far the lion’s share of capital investment will be taken up by the “vital” New Forth Crossing and new Glasgow Southern General hospital. Transport in general fares well with priority status given to upgrades to the strategic road network including the M8, M73 & M74 Improvement Programme and Aberdeen Western Peripheral Route.
Broadband and so called digital infrastructure also receives priority in the plan. The financial crisis demonstrated underperformance in exports and in today’s global market place the internet provides a portal to the world. Productivity gains and the potential to connect an otherwise potentially remote Scottish market into the heart of the global market place makes it a desirable area for the government to invest. The government hope to leverage additional funding from the private sector to extend high speed internet access throughout Scotland including to the most rural areas.
The need to leverage in additional funding to boost the core capital budget is evidenced elsewhere too. Through its Scottish Futures Trust the Scottish Government has announced a £2.5bn pipeline of ‘revenue funded’ projects largely in the social infrastructure sector with initial projects including schools and FE colleges. These projects will utilise the Non Profit Distributing (NPD) model an updated version of the PFI model which delivers capital investment upfront and is typically repaid from revenue budgets through a unitary charge over a 25 year period. The fact that education appears to have been prioritised is no surprise given its long term importance to economic growth and the worrying figures on youth unemployment. Other measures include using Network Rail's Regulated Asset Base borrowing capacity for the Borders Railway and the Glasgow - Edinburgh improvements programme.
In total the combination of capital budget and other measures to support investment is intended to generate infrastructure investment of £12bn over the next three years.
Stimulating Private Sector Investment
Maintaining investment in infrastructure has a second positive dividend which goes someway to addressing the second challenge facing Mr Swinney of stimulating private sector growth. If public sector projects can get to market quickly, however financed, then they should provide a short term ‘Keynesian style’ stimulus to the economy, for example by providing additional jobs in the construction sector which was hard hit during the recession. History suggests, however, that revenue funded projects in particular can take a long time to come to the market in the UK. Perhaps there is a role for Government to examine how this time might be reduced to levels closer to those seen in continental Europe such that the opportunity for shorter term stimulus is not missed.
Just as he has prioritised investment in infrastructure the Finance Secretary also appears to have taken a strategic approach to boosting growth in the private sector, targeting additional support to key sectors where Scotland already has, or might be able to build, competitive advantage. These include Low Carbon Industries, Renewable Energy, Life Sciences and Manufacturing. Here it is hoped that targeted investment and support by the public sector might find it easiest to have a bigger impact by attracting multiples of subsequent investment from the private sector. The confirmation in the budget of 4 new Enterprise Areas, which are likely to follow their counterpart Enterprise Zones in England in offering incentives such as a more favourable business rate regime, more generous capital allowances and access to high speed broadband, should benefit these sectors in particular.
It is perhaps in the renewables arena where the government has been most "strategic" in its attempts to open private sector pockets and it has set a very positive "tone from the top" to attract investors.
It is perhaps in the renewables arena where the government has been most ‘strategic’ in its attempts to open private sector pockets and it has set a very positive “tone from the top” to attract investors. The scale of the investment challenge is potentially huge. PwC estimated around £30bn of investment would be required to build out existing offshore leases in Scottish territorial waters, and it is not yet clear where such resources will be found. Sovereign wealth and pension funds remain cherished targets but much needs to be done to de-risk the renewables industry sufficiently to attract investment. Here the public sector should consider how to put its scarce resources to best use. Prioritising technologies with the most realistic deliverability and extending the reach of its funding through intelligent co-investment and recycling of funds where possible would help leverage maximum input from the private sector and maximise both the economic and carbon impact. The Fossil Fuel Levy and Green Investment Bank, neither factored into the budget, will prove important in this regard.
Making the Most of It
Perhaps the lesson that should be taken away is that the challenge and scale of investment required remains huge across the public sector estate and to convert big growth opportunities like renewables. Mr Swinney's budget represents a good start. He had little scope for manoeuvre but in choosing to prioritise capital investment in infrastructure, make use of new funding models and act as a strategic investor in key sectors he has made at least a stab at maximising its impact.
Paul Brewer is Senior Partner, Edinburgh Office. PricewaterhouseCoopers LLP. Paul leads PwC's Government & Public Sector practice in Scotland and is a corporate financier specialising in the financing and delivery of large infrastructure and renewables projects.
By Paul Brewer, Senior Partner, PricewaterhouseCoopers LLP
OTHER ARTICLES IN THIS ISSUE
- Editorial
- The Role of the Scottish Budget in Stimulating Investment
- In My View...
- The Evolving Public Sector Response to Budget Challenges
- Welfare Reform - Lone Parents Caught in the Cross-Fire
- A Tale of Two City Strategies
- A Digital Soapbox
- Searching for Scotland's 'Green Gold' - A Reader Writes
Issue 2: March 2012
SCOTTISH BUDGET, PUBLIC SECTOR REFORM, CITIES POLICY AND THIS ISSUE'S POLICY FOCUS - CARE AND HEALTH
Nicola Sturgeon's Ambitions for Care & Health
Nicola Sturgeon gave the keynote speech at the recent MacKay Hannah conference on Care and Health. Afterwards she spoke with Scottish Policy Now on the integration of care services.
PREVIOUS ISSUES
Looking for a previous issue? Use the menu below to select an issue.
MOST READ ARTICLES
- Bringing alive the Digital Participation Charter for Scotland's citizens, communities and businesses
- Transport for Edinburgh - Integrated Transport for a Smart City
- Worth more than the First Minister? Senior Salaries in Scottish Quangos
- A Planet of Smart Cities: Scotland's digital challenge
- Dundee: From Waterfront redevelopment to city economy regeneration
- Social Business Can Transform Public Services
- Success secrets shared: Learning from the best Mittelstand and British global niche champions
- Public Services Reform and Public Opinion
- Increasing digital participation levels in Scotland - what needs to happen next?
- The Evolving Public Sector Response to Budget Challenges