CAN GREEN SPACE BEAT ANXIETY IN URBAN SCOTLAND?
By Dr Jenny Roe
Last month, a survey by the Office of National Statistics indicated 39% of Scottish people (aged 16 and over) have reported ‘high’ or ’ very high’ levels of anxiety – and across the UK mixed anxiety and depression is the UK’s most common mental disorder presenting a major challenge for the future in health, economic and social terms. The cost of mental illness to the UK economy was recently reported to cost some £80 million annually.
Whilst Cognitive Behaviour Therapy (CBT) is a tried and trusted method of treating mental health problems - and National Institute for Heath and Care Excellence (NICE) approved – there are long waiting lists and the NHS only provide six sessions per patient. So there is an urgent need to find other less expensive, simple solutions that can help on a daily basis.
Anxiety UK www.anxietyuk.org.uk recommends exercise – an activity that could be further enhanced by walking in an attractive local park or nearby woodland. These natural environments not only make a place more pleasant in which to walk, they offer recuperation from fatigue and stress because they hold our attention with little effort – what’s called by Kaplan and Kaplan ‘soft fascination’. This mental health benefit of green space is called ‘psychological restoration’ and has mostly been studied using subjective measures of stress and wellbeing. But now there is new evidence from a study carried out in Scotland which has used an objective, physiological measure of stress to show the potential importance of green space for people under stress in areas of urban deprivation.
…there is an urgent need to find, simple solutions for anxiety that can help on a daily basis.
Cortisol acts as a stress biomarker but has rarely been used before as part of methods to explore how the different attributes of our built environment may act to exacerbate, or relieve, stress for those going about their everyday lives in urban environments.
Our data – rigorously measured and analysed statistically controlling for confounders such as income deprivation – illustrates that green space appears to help buffer stress for those living in poverty in deprived cities. The effect appears to be stronger for women, whose diurnal patterns of cortisol showed greater hypocortisolemia (i.e. unusually low, constant levels of cortisol), indicative of chronic stress and exhaustion, for those living in areas with little green space when compared to those living with higher levels of green space, whose diurnal cortisol patterns indicated better stress regulation. This is an important result because dysregulation of the daily pattern of cortisol secretion, part of our circadian rhythms, is associated with an array of negative health outcomes including major depressive disorders.
It is interesting that the patterns we found in cortisol were also reflected in our data on perceived levels of stress, with both men and women reporting lower perceived stress in areas with more green space, and women reporting higher perceived stress in areas with low levels of green space.
“These results are important in understanding how neighbourhood green space might contribute to public health improvement. Stress is known to impact on cardiovascular health, alongside other risk factors such as genetics, age, diet and physical activity, but little is known about the contributions of environmental factors.“ Jenny Roe
We are not suggesting green space can solve the problems of major life stressors - redundancy bereavement, divorce – but, at a time when both our own and international health and welfare services are evaluating new approaches to the wellbeing of our growing populations, we believe our study is an important indication of the potential positive emotional impact of providing access to green space.
Dr Jenny Roe is at University of York and is writing as part of a research team that includes: Catharine Ward Thompson, Peter A. Aspinall, Mark J. Brewer, Elizabeth I. Duff, David Miller, Richard Mitchell and Angela Clow. Her web page can be found here: Jenny Roe
By Dr Jenny Roe
Issue 7: Nov 2013
HEALTH, WELL BEING AND AGEING: SCOTLAND 2020
Scotland's move to integrated care can learn from elsewhere by focussing on two key differentiators between successful partnerships and those paying lip service to integrated working: Shared outcomes and common language is one, the other is demonstrating mutual investments and mutual benefits.
- Scotland: Caring for the carers
- We should have fewer Councils - but they should run health
- Sustainable Communities - a Long Term view of Health and Social Care
- Stubbing it out: how can this be measured?
- A big Scottish question - "how do we become a healthier people?"
- Who's caring for ...our grandparents ...children ...us?
- Growing Old and Falling Apart - It doesn't have to be that way....
- NHS Scotland: the public and the patients
- A postcard from Older Scotland in 2020
- Equality: the last hurdle. Or is it ?
- Redressing Health Delivery in Scotland
OTHER ARTICLES IN THIS ISSUE
- Editorial: Policy Making and Data. Count me in! ..But can you really count?
- We have a right to know
- Interview: Danny Alexander MP, Chief Secretary to the Treasury
- Transport investment: a key part of economic recovery
- Planning for your/our pension futures?
- Launch of Commission for Strengthening Local Democracy
- People Power: Why Employers Should Invest for Success
- Are we really crossing the digital divide?
- Making it local and integrated in Argyll & Bute
- Social Productivity - what it means for Scotland's environment
- Supporting Independent Renewable Energy
Looking for a previous issue? Use the menu below to select an issue.
MOST READ ARTICLES
- Transport for Edinburgh - Integrated Transport for a Smart City
- Bringing alive the Digital Participation Charter for Scotland's citizens, communities and businesses
- Social Business Can Transform Public Services
- Worth more than the First Minister? Senior Salaries in Scottish Quangos
- Dundee: From Waterfront redevelopment to city economy regeneration
- Public Services Reform and Public Opinion
- Increasing digital participation levels in Scotland - what needs to happen next?
- A Planet of Smart Cities: Scotland's digital challenge
- The Evolving Public Sector Response to Budget Challenges
- Telehealth and Telecare for Older People